Reviews For Please
You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: Nieriel Raina Anonymous [Report This]
Date: 28/02/09 - 03:18 am Title: Please

This is very sweet, but elves don't sink in snow. They walk on top of it as Legolas did in FotR!

Naneth only has two 'n's and not in a row. :)

Thranduil would call Varda by her Sindarin name - Elbereth.

If Thranduil is shortening Legolas's name to just be "Leaf" it would revert to the actual Sindarin word, which is spelled 'lass'.
I enjoyed this very much, despite the pickies though. :)

Reviewer: Henoluin_Elsilim Signed [Report This]
Date: 20/01/09 - 07:05 pm Title: Please

Awww.... *sniffle* that was so sweet! *is tearing up* =')

Author's Response: I love little Legolas and I love Thranduil. I thought they should have a reunion with someone they hold close. Thanks for reading!

Reviewer: caladhiel amariel Signed [Report This]
Date: 28/12/08 - 01:28 pm Title: Please

What a touching story! Lovely and well written, i thoroughly enjoyed reading this; little Legolas is so cute!

Author's Response: Grown up Legolas is cute too:)) Thanks for reading!

Reviewer: xFanarix Signed [Report This]
Date: 08/12/08 - 06:51 am Title: Please

It's a nice thought. Unfortunately the Elves who heeded the call of Mandos and were re-housed in bodies again, remained in Aman. They would not appear as ' ghosts ', the only Elves who would, are the ' houseless fŰa ' who refused the call on Mandos and remained on Middle-earth. death was ' not considered a sufficient reason ' ( Morgoth's Ring ) for the easy return of those reborn in Valinor.

I would accept Legolas having a dream of his mother, but unless she was one of the ' houseless ' not Thranduil and Legolas both seeing some sort of vision of her.

It was one of the griefs of the Elves, that they remembered everything with clarity ( for how could a well-nigh ageless race live if they had memories as defective as Mortals? ) and had to endure the loss and separation of their kin until they were reunited in Valinor. Although it's sweet and fluffy to imagine, the Elves were not that lucky, to be granted * visitations * from their loved ones. It's part of what makes their history so sorrowful.

One of the most interesting ficlets I have read dealing with this, is The Ghost in the Garden by Dawn Felagund, who knows Tolkien inside out and backwards. It is rated teens and the main characters are Galadriel and Celeborn. It is well worth a read.

Author's Response: I guess I didn't really think about that. But, I knew someone else had already done a story about Legolas seeing his mother in a dream. I think I've read the Ghost in the Garden but I'll check it out again sometime.

Reviewer: Kitt Otter Signed [Report This]
Date: 07/12/08 - 10:06 pm Title: Please

Beautiful and... eerie is not quite the word. It was delicate. Thranduil is so loving and Legolas sweet.
It was breathtaking to learn how it came about - that Varda had answered his prayer.
-Kitt

Author's Response: Thanks. I guess I get the flashback from 'LOST'. Have you seen it? I want to thank you for reading and reviewing all of my things. Every time I post something I always here from you. It makes me want to continue writing.

You must login (register) to review.