Who's Online:
Members:
I don't usually like the Fellowship-as-children genre, but this is charming. I liked your foreshadowing to events of LotR, and I like your use of words, eg, "the future oliphaunt-slayer of Mirkwood scampered".
Author's Response: Haha, I'm so glad! Thank you!
Most excellent crossover. Movie Legolas and do make a good vapid comic duo. It's the hair, I think.
RS
Most excellent crossover. Movie Legolas and do make a good vapid comic duo. It's the hair, I think.
RS
Heheh. Shades of Colin Powell -- I like the idea of the ring as a publicity stunt.
Hey, I used to love the Princess and the Goblin! I like the way you shone the light on a minor character.
This story is a unique, squishy gem.
I loved this story. It inspired one of mine.
I like your creation of a historical root for the elanor.
Author's Response: Dear Ria, I\'m so glad you enjoyed it, and huzzah! It inspired another story? Excellent! Thank you for reviewing - happy reading and writing!\r\n\r\nDwim
So this is a Troy fic rather than an Iliad. It's funny, of course, because Achilles was dressed up as a girl for some of his earlier years, when his mother still hoped to keep him from joining in the war. The feminine form of the name would be Achilleis, like Chryseis the daughter of Chryses.
A very interesting concept.
Oh, excellent! This is the first song of your set that I really know and you did it justice.
Author's Response: Hi Ria,
I\'m so glad you enjoyed this one! Paul Simon is a wonderful lyricist; there\'s so much to play with for a filker.
Thanks for commenting!
Dwim
You should add this to Elvenlily's "The Phantom of Middle Earth" challenge. I think you came up with a great interpretation of this song.
Funny, funny! This is like the book A Field Guide to the Urban Hipster. Do the whole taxonomy, please, Professor.
Make sure you include the Flame-haired emerald-eyed Sue! The hobbit girl in Case Study 5 doesn't actually sound like a Sue in her description, although Frodo's response marks her as a possible crypto-Sue.
I don't particularly consider that disturbing. Now, when he leaves Legolas for Gollum ...
This chapter is very elegantly written, and I especially like Eowyn's last line.
Radagast as a female may well be one of my all time favorite AU ideas. Thanks for bringing it to this site. It's also great that she acts to keep the balance, which seems very Maia-like.
Sounds like a great setting. I've always wondered how they dealt with the remaining orcs in the resettling of Ithilien . . . plus Shelob's still there. Many adventures are possible for Fey.
Editorial note: Faramir should be poring over documents, rather than pouring. They're homophones.
RS
Author's Response: thank you so much for reviewing. Poring, not pouring, right. thank you, i\'ll change it now. Again, thank you.
Helen
I've always wanted to know what happened when Legolas and Gimli sailed west . . . This is a good idea. Also, hooray for writing a story about Gimli!
I have to agree with Nieriel Raina that there are rather a lot of lines from the movies in an otherwise very original story.
Author's Response: Yeah, there probably are. This was one of the first fics I ever wrote, so it is definitely not the greatest.
Bravo! That's a clever and logical crossover.
RS
Author's Response: Hehe. Thank you very much! I\'m glad you approve! ^___^
This is a great idea for a story, and I entirely agree that Galadriel would be a Ravenclaw.
As a matter of site protocol, please, please don't use multi-repeated characters as separators. Two or three asterisks, max, please.