Reviews by Twilight
The Black Rose by Gemini_Elf Rated: PG-13 [Reviews - 55]
Summary: This story has been completely and fully edited. Several chapters have been taken out and re-written and others have been collapsed to make shorter, and an OC has been cut out. If you have read this before, I advise re-reading it to catch up
Enemies from the past are coming back to haunt Elrond and Thranduil, and what better way to get at a Father, than to kidnap a son? Aragorn and Legolas are in trouble. Big Trouble

Categories: Movie-verse Characters: Aragorn, Elladan, Elrohir, Elrond, Erestor, Glorfindel, Legolas, Thranduil
Genres: Action/Adventure, Angst
Warnings: AU (alternate universe), Character Death, Torture
Series: Eternal Mellyn
Chapters: 13 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 15896 Read Count: 22814
Published: Nov 05 2006 Updated: Jul 05 2008 [Report This]
Title: Chapter 3: Awakenings Reviewer: Twilight Signed
Ooh...scary. Legolas and Aragorn didn't meet though... :(
But plot was really good. It will be interesting to see how this all works out... nice work so far! Your imagery is pwnful, I can imagine being there.

Author's Response: pwnful? Um...Not familiar with that word ^_^ Don\'t worry, Aragorn and Las will meet soon enough! (Although more pleasant circumstances would have been nicer for both!)
Date: Jun 11 2007
Title: Chapter 4: The Meeting Reviewer: Twilight Signed
The beginning was kind of confusing, being who was who and what they looked like (ie positions) But other than that, I'm still interested. This just keeps on getting better because...
Evil lady and my two favorite people ever, yep, perfect story.
In fact, that's what I'm writing about now.
Dunno if you've finished this yet, (though I will soon)
But keep writing!

Author's Response: There\'s too many male villains, so I wanted a girl ^_^ More fun.
Date: Jun 11 2007
Title: Chapter 6: Not just a messenger... Reviewer: Twilight Signed
Ha ha...
Cliff hangers no workie for when I am reading this when you've already posted, lucky you.
Other wise, I'd have to torture you and TRY not to kill you so you can inform me of what happens.
Dude, you like, totally stole my plot.
The 'your sons will die so I can rule' whole thing
You know...
That is so not fair... tnf.
Shame, shame... :(

Author's Response: _ It\'s an ANCIENT plot. Something prehistoric people would have been telling around campfires. And technically, it\'s not a \"your sons will die so I will rule\" thing, it\'s a \"your sons will die because you killed/tried to kill me\" Ok, admittedly Durband DID try taking the throne from Thranduil, but Morwen\'s just evil. And wants revenge. (By the way, if you were joking, I have a tendency to take everything to heart, so people normally have to tell me they\'re joking.)
Date: Jun 11 2007
Title: The Black Rose Reviewer: Twilight Signed
Nicely done, Niphredil... :P

Author's Response: I know :D
Date: Jun 11 2007
Title: Chapter 7: Discussions Reviewer: Twilight Signed

Author's Response: Not very much content in that chapter...
Date: Jun 11 2007
Title: Chapter 10: A sacrifice Reviewer: Twilight Signed
Do not torture me with self-sacrifice on Amren's part...
you evil elf... :K
That's my job.

Author's Response: I know...I\'m evil! :D Aw, but I\'m on the good guy\'s side really...I just like writing stories which involve Elves and fighting! ^_^
Date: Jun 11 2007
Title: The Black Rose Reviewer: Twilight Signed
You. Better. Have. An. Update.
Mwah ha hah... :P
Nicely done. Please do a sequel/update... I love this!

Author's Response: Right, good news, I am writing the last chapter *Does happy dance* Bad news: Dunno when it\'ll be finished!
Date: Jun 11 2007
Title: Chapter 1: The First Move... Reviewer: Twilight Signed
Ooh... interesting. I haven't read a good fic for a while... I'm adding this to my favorites. You've got my attention now... :P

Author's Response: O.O I could not BELIEVE it when my inbox said I have nine reviews. Thank you SO much! ^_^ I\'m glad you think it\'s good! And *Hugs* thank you for adding it to your favs!
Date: Jun 11 2007
Title: Chapter 2: The Ambush Reviewer: Twilight Signed
So I guess Legolas and Aragorn will meet now that they are both alive and hit by orcs? I love Legolas and Aragorn... can't wait to read more. I like your style of writing, you portray the characters pretty well. Keep it up!

Author's Response: I love them too ^_^ Although you wouldn\'t know, the amount of trouble I write them into!
Date: Jun 11 2007
Title: The Black Rose Reviewer: Twilight Signed
Ai. Half of those reviews... more than half, to be precise, I was joking. I know, it's hard to tell when I write stuff. But whenever I include ':P' anywhere in the review, it means I'm joking. I love this story... and I'm glad you are updating soon.... else I really would have to kill you.


Now that there was contradictory...but I'll let you decide. "D

Author's Response: I\'m very happy to know you were joking. yeah, it is hard, most of the time I sound sarcastic, when I don\'t mean to. I HOPE I update soon *Hides so you can\'t kill me* I was writing some in Physics, but I might re-write it. But it should be up soon, hoping to get it done before my birthday (Eeep! Only a week to go!)
Date: Jun 12 2007