Reviews by Pink Siamese
Summary: In the near future, as the Age of Men begins to crumble, the truth is revealed about a long-vanished world that no one, except perhaps a few, even knows existed. MEFA 2008 third-place winner, incomplete AU category.
Categories: Book-verse Characters: Elladan, Elrohir, Gandalf / Olorin, Maglor, Original Character
Genres: Drama, Mystery
Warnings: AU (alternate universe)
Series: None
Chapters: 30 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 52101 Read Count: 46385
Published: Nov 19 2006 Updated: Aug 06 2008 [Report This]
Title: Chapter 30: Kindness Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
I started reading this (having picked it at random from the updates column) as a sort of brain Drano from writing my own fic and was astounded at its depth and quality and how damn entertaining it was. I've often thought of writing a story like this one, where ME intrudes and/or melds somewhat with our modern world, and I can say with all honesty that this is the kind of story I wish I could write.

Very well done. I do hope you decide to write sequels/prequels. I'd be very interested in reading them.

Author's Response: Thank you. I'll try.
Date: Aug 07 2008
Mary Sue Productions by Ria Rated: PG [Reviews - 9]
Summary: A sideways look at the effect of non-canonical fiction.
Categories: Movie-verse Characters: Faramir, Feanor, Figwit, Frodo Gamgee, Gollum, Maglor, Orcs/Uruk-Hai
Genres: Parody
Warnings: AU (alternate universe)
Series: Saturday's Children
Chapters: 3 Table of Contents
Completed: No Word count: 3278 Read Count: 5542
Published: Mar 10 2007 Updated: Apr 22 2007 [Report This]
Title: Chapter 1: All the Steps Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
Oh, man. That's awesome. Just awesome.

Author's Response: Thanks.
Date: Nov 02 2008
Summary: A Dunedain king still sits upon the throne of Rhudaur, but can he endure when faced with both an upstart hillman chieftain and the Witch-king of Angmar? Northern Kingdom Writers present a tale of intrigues and sorcery, treason and loyalty, cruelty and love will take the readers to Cameth Brin, Amon Sűl and Carn Dűm, letting them experience the dangers of 14 century Arnor. Based on LOTR Appendix A, the story is canon-mindful.
The first Part of the story is complete!
Categories: Book-verse Characters: Frodo, Gandalf / Olorin, Glorfindel, Merry, Nazgűl, Orcs/Uruk-Hai, Pippin, Sam, Witch King
Genres: Action/Adventure, Angst, Drama, Romance, Tragedy
Warnings: Character Death, Rape, Torture, Violence
Series: The Shadow Over Rhudaur
Chapters: 24 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 56268 Read Count: 59259
Published: May 07 2007 Updated: Aug 06 2007 [Report This]
Title: Chapter 1: The Prologue -A Story about the Rescue of Princesses Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
I completely adore this prologue. I love the concept of presenting it in 'campfire tale' form first---narrated by a bard in a safe environment with all the messy details streamlined and organized into resonance. Then going back in future chapters and telling it again, with all the confusion and grit and contradictions. I've never seen a prologue like this before. Excellent!

Author's Response: Than you, Pink Siamese, for your kind words. We did indeed put a lot of work in the Prologue. I will copy your review and post it on our site - it will cheer the others up. Greetings, Gordis.
Date: Nov 20 2007
Summary: A poem I wrote for a special Elf at the time of Summer Solstice, 1986. I had painstakingly did it in Calligraphy on parchment and presented it to her in a glassed frame. She was mildly amused. Alas! It did not win her heart. Neither did she notice the message in the vertical column. Ah! The foolish things I did for love when I was younger!
Categories: Off Topic Characters: None
Genres: Poetry
Warnings: None
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 61 Read Count: 2749
Published: Dec 22 2007 Updated: Dec 22 2007 [Report This]
Title: Chapter 1: A Solstice for Andrea Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
That's beautiful. I'm of the firm opinion that it was her loss. ;-)

Author's Response: Thanks. You're sweet! I thought that this poem had, by now, been long buried and forgotten in one of Minas Tirith's dusty archive vaults. It's very gratifying to learn that someone has taken the time to look over some of my older stuff.
Date: Dec 20 2008
Summary: Alianariasëaefala Oenalarsafalothanarien Jaharanalercotania is the most beautiful girl in all of Middleearth. As are Zenara Warrior Princess Ranger of the North, Brittney Julia Rebecca Mary Sue Sarah Brianna Forest, and Aquamarine Moonbeam Sunlight Stardust Flowerpetal Fairyglitter Waterstone Firebird. They are slowly taking over the world . . . and none have the power to stop them . . . except for one.
Enter Gimli Son of Gloin.
Categories: Book-verse, Movie-verse Characters: Gimli, Original Character, The Fellowship
Genres: Action/Adventure, Horror, Humor, Parody
Warnings: Torture
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: No Word count: 1425 Read Count: 2709
Published: Jan 04 2008 Updated: Jan 04 2008 [Report This]
Title: Chapter 1: "Not more of them!" Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
Okay, that's pretty funny. ;-)

Author's Response: Thanks! :D
Date: Oct 24 2008
Summary: Response to the "Why I review Fanfiction" challenge put fourth by Karlmir Stonewain
Categories: Off Topic Characters: None
Genres: Other
Warnings: None
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 1607 Read Count: 2125
Published: Feb 10 2008 Updated: Feb 10 2008 [Report This]
Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1 Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
I have to disagree, but only partially, with your criticisms regarding Mary Sue/self insert stories. I would argue that creating an additional character, placing him/her within the narrative, and using that vantage point to both view and interact with the canon is possibly the best way to explore Middle-earth through one's own writing. (I'm trying to quote you from memory, and I'm probably sucking.) I agree that to pull it off properly requires a level of skill that most MS/TW authors simply don't have. They can't really be blamed; they are for the most part inexperienced writers interacting with the text, and lots of times they are young people with little life experience and most of what they've learned about sex and relationships has come out of reading romance novels.

Author's Response: Hello Pink, I applogize as I only now realized that you had reviewed this and I do make an effort to reply to all reviews and I do thank you for yours as you have definately given me something to think on as I never looked at it that way. I am definately all for younger readers exploring Middle Earth, In fact I think it is wonderful when someone younger can tear themselves away from twitter and facebook and whatever else is popular to pick up a book that they will read and enjoy so much that they want to explore it further. I wrote this essay a while back and I have softened my stance on Mary sues as there are groups out there who for some reason make a point or pursuing stories that contain what they feel is a sue I am no longer so bothered as when I started to write my very first attempt was very much a sue and so it was really hypocritical of me. I know that if someone had come along and torn me apart that I would have been so upset that I would have given up on writing all together but fortunately that was not the case so it is really not fair of me, I do try to offer advice when I can to younger writers to improve as that is what really helped me along when I was getting started. Thank you again for your review, you have truly given me something to mull over.
Date: Apr 08 2009
Summary: Just some silly musings!
Categories: Off Topic Characters: Maglor, Original Character
Genres: Humor
Warnings: Slash (same sex pairing)
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 1044 Read Count: 2064
Published: Jun 23 2008 Updated: Jun 23 2008 [Report This]
Title: Chapter 1: What are fanfiction characters doing, while ... Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
LOL...sometimes I write what I call "Green Room Fics," where all the characters that I write about are waiting in the green room, waiting for their turn on the "stage." I haven't written one in awhile, but when I get really going into a story, once in awhile the silliness will spill out. Very entertaining, though I don't think someone who isn't a writer will get it. ;-)

Author's Response:
Glad you liked it. Might be that not everyone will understand it, but when I wrote it, I needed to get it off my mind, as it did not let me rest. Was the first thing I ever posted, I suppose there are still some mistakes in it as well, as it was not properly beta-ed.

I had musings in such a direction as well, a parody. Imagining all the fanfics were played in some kind of giant theatre, with different staged. The characters spend most of their time there, practicing their parts or playing for the audience. There is a large, luxurious area where the characters can go to relax, talk or be in private. A very noble restaurant, with all the favorite food and drink of the characters (e.g. Sauron’s favorite tea is ‘Speacial Mordor Blend’ tee leaves hand picked by elvish slaves.) There is a lounge for them to read favorite books (e.g. Celeborn reading: My insignificant life at the side of a strong woman – learning how to accept it) one to listen to music, … I wrote some small drafts in German a while ago, but cannot find them any longer. The thoughts urged me into manipulating with some pictures, Glorfindel practicing some scenes, riding on a giant, wooden Asfaloth … naked.
Date: Feb 11 2009
Summary: A heroic tale of a young Orc soldier searching for his destiny in a world without Sauron.
Categories: Movie-verse, Off Topic Characters: Saradoc Brandybuck, Saruman, Sauron
Genres: Action/Adventure
Warnings: AU (alternate universe)
Series: None
Chapters: 2 Table of Contents
Completed: No Word count: 1263 Read Count: 5144
Published: Sep 28 2008 Updated: Oct 29 2008 [Report This]
Title: Chapter 1: Prologue Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
I like the attitude behind this very much. There aren't enough writers putting thought into Orcish culture. Please continue with this.
Date: Oct 29 2008
Summary: Valinor/Middle Earth communications in the Fourth Age.
Categories: Book-verse, Movie-verse Characters: Aragorn, Celeborn, Frodo, Galadriel, Sam
Genres: Essay
Warnings: None
Series: Arda Musings
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 507 Read Count: 2453
Published: Oct 02 2008 Updated: Oct 02 2008 [Report This]
Title: Chapter 1: Letters from the Undying Lands Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
I think this makes a lot of sense as long as there are still a few random Elves lingering in Middle-earth. Once all of them have departed, I imagine they'd take their ships back to Valinor and that would be the end of any traffic. While it's easy to take a more emotional view of the Tolkienverse, as writers of fanfic it's good for us to remember that Tolkien wrote these stories as a history, and that in the matter of history practicalities still apply. Elves strive to live in harmony with the natural world---that they would denude the forests in order to avoid reusing ships is antithetical to what we know of their race. Their reverence for forests is a defining characteristic. That alone supports the idea that they would keep the shipping lines open, so to speak. As long as the shipping lines are open, what is it to carry a little mail now and then?

Author's Response: I believe that there would still be a substantial number of Elves remaining in Middle Earth during the early decades of the Fourth Age. At this time, Thranduil's kingdom is still flourishing in the north and Celeborn is founding East Lorien. I'm certain that a small number of diehard Elves would still be living in Lothlorien for a few decades after Galadriel sailed to the West. And Legolas must have had a substantial community of followers if they were to beautify and manage Greenwood in Ithilien after the War of the Ring. I'm basing most of these ideas from what I've read in "The Atlas of Middle Earth" and "The Complete Guide to Middle Earth".

Besides mail, I don't think it would be unreasonable to assume that a limited amount of trade goods and/or gifts would also be carried. In the above mentioned chapter of "Arwen's Journey", Aragorn alludes to a small cask of fine pipeweed which Evenstar had previously sent to our Hobbit hero.

My profuse thanks for your thoughtful and insightful review.
Date: Oct 13 2008
Summary: just my feelings on alot of random stuff.
Categories: Off Topic Characters: None
Genres: None
Warnings: None
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 168 Read Count: 1727
Published: Oct 29 2008 Updated: Oct 29 2008 [Report This]
Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1 Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
And you forgot one: who cares if Obama is Muslim? Religious affiliation has absolutely nothing to do with the ability to run the country.

Aw shit, she's going to run in 2012? Oh man the Mayans had it right. The world is totally going to end. ::shudders::
Date: Oct 30 2008
Summary: Lindir the elfling talks to his Uncle Erestor about elves marrying orcs and the Black Speech.
Categories: Book-verse, Movie-verse Characters: Erestor, Lindir
Genres: General, Humor
Warnings: None
Series: None
Chapters: 1 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 539 Read Count: 1579
Published: Nov 05 2008 Updated: Nov 05 2008 [Report This]
Title: Chapter 1: Young Lindir, Orcs and the Black Speech Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
Very nice work.

Author's Response: Thank you, Pink Siamese. Happy you enjoyed it.
Date: Nov 05 2008
Summary: For anybody else who has ever felt that they need to hide their fanfic habit. Rated PG for one instance of bad language.
Categories: Off Topic Characters: None
Genres: Essay
Warnings: None
Series: None
Chapters: 12 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 10094 Read Count: 18791
Published: Feb 08 2009 Updated: Oct 14 2010 [Report This]
Title: Chapter 1: Narya's thoughts Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
Thanks for the shout-out! ;-) I'll say it loud and I'll say it proud---I am a big huge brainy geek. It's unfortunate that you feel like "geek" is an unflattering word; is there anything better than losing oneself in intellectual pursuits? You should be proud of your intelligence and remember that there are people out there who would die to be half as smart as you are.

Author's Response: Like I was saying to Anwyn, I really try to take it as a compliment when somebody calls me a geek, but it's something that various people have always made me feel ashamed of. And you're very welcome :) thank you for contributing! "You are a writer" - I certainly feel like one now I've read your essay. Totally inspiring. It's very true that so many people claim to be writers, or express ambitions to become one, and yet barely ever put pen to paper/fingers to keyboard. Reading your thoughts has given me more self-belief and confidence in my identity; I've never had anything published, but since I do write every day, I now feel that I can officially call myself a writer. Thank you.
Date: Feb 08 2009
Title: Chapter 8: An Update From Narya Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
Awhile back I came across a story in a Southern Lit anthology that turned out to be a fanfiction based on one of William Faulkner's short stories (A Rose For Emily). I squeed so loud that I startled my mother. ;) But yeah, derivative works have been around as long as...well, as the works they're derived from. Neil Gaiman wrote Chronicles of Narnia fanfiction ("The Problem of Susan") and of course there's Pride and Prejudice and Zombies. The film 10 Things I Hate About You is a reinterpretation of Shakespeare's The Taming Of The Shrew. So yeah, the list goes on and on. I'll continue to maintain that people who loathe fanfiction feel threatened by it on some deep level. I suppose on some level it kills the myth of being "original," and an insecure artist is usually the first to tell you how "original" their original fiction is. At bottom everything is derivative, either from art or from life.

Author's Response: Oooh - what's the name of the Faulkner-based story? And I think I need to read "The Problem of Susan" too; is it about how she grew away from the other three children? Gah, I guess I'll read and find out. " I'll continue to maintain that people who loathe fanfiction feel threatened by it on some deep level" - probably true, but I wonder why they feel that way?
Date: Jul 03 2009
Second Chance by Narya Rated: PG-13 half-star [Reviews - 150]
Summary: When fifteen-year-old Anna loses her sister in a freak horseriding accident, she has no way of knowing that Izzy has been given another chance to live and love. However, the afterlife works in mysterious ways; soon Anna is plagued by dreams that link her to a young woman from an age long, long forgotten, and to a blue-eyed foal that she has a nagging feeling she should recognise...

A response to Dunedain Ranger of the North's "Animal Transformations" challenge. Rated PG-13 for character death, emotional content and some mild language.
Categories: Book-verse, Movie-verse, Crossovers Characters: Original Character
Genres: Angst, Drama, Family, Friendship, Hurt/Comfort, Other
Warnings: Character Death
Challenges: Animal Transformations
Series: Second Chance
Chapters: 31 Table of Contents
Completed: Yes Word count: 64189 Read Count: 40654
Published: Feb 12 2009 Updated: Apr 16 2010 [Report This]
Title: Chapter 1: Prologue Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
I really love what you're doing with this story. Another reason the Rohirrim may geld their horses would have to do with the organization of bloodlines---they'd be keeping some sort of breeding records, at the very least to prevent accidental inbreeding, and also to document exceptional lineage. Once a stallion has sired x-number of colts, snipetty-snip. I'm looking forward to the big climax, where people start to figure out what's going on. :)

Author's Response: Oooh, I never thought of that as a possibility - thanks, Pink! I'm glad you're enjoying it still; the lights are going to start witching on very soon! Thank you for the review :-)
Date: May 28 2009
Title: Chapter 1: Prologue Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
Is this going to be in parts?

Author's Response: Yeah, I tend to write several stories at once...this one isn't going to be long, though. Two or three chapters plus the prologue, I reckon.
Date: Feb 12 2009
Title: Chapter 1: Prologue Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
I write several stories at once, too. I know how it is. ;-)

Author's Response: Hehe even so I think with this one and the other two fanfics I have on the go, plus my original stuff, I have enough to work on for now!!
Date: Feb 12 2009
Title: Chapter 4: Interlude Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
I patiently await the revelation. :)

Author's Response: Teehee :) won't be long! Thank you for R&Ring.
Date: May 12 2009
Title: Chapter 25: The First Through The Wardrobe Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
YAY OMG LOVE! ::incoherent fangirl fluttering:: C.S Lewis reference for the win! Mr. Proust FOR THE WIN! (Someday I will be more coherent about this, I swear.)

Author's Response: Haha, incoherent is cool :D I'm glad people seem to like this chapter; this is one of the scenes that's been in the brewing for a long, long time! Thanks for reading and leaving feedback - I've got way behind on Dawn, I need to catch up. I think I might go back and reread from the start.
Date: Feb 01 2010
Title: Chapter 8: Dinner and a Discovery Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
I could really just hijack most of Spiced Wine's review...the dialogue in this chapter is superb: natural rhythm, lovely pacing, and a deepening level of intimacy that is skillfully handled and believably presented. I love how you're revealing the story to us a little bit at a time, creating a little bit of that same intimacy between the story and the reader, which of course draws us in ever tighter. And the cliffie is great! Lovely work, as usual. ;)

Author's Response: I could really just hijack most of Spiced Wine's review...woot! Thank you so much *glows* when I get a nice review from you, SW or both, it's like a teacher putting a gold star on my work - makes my day! Like I was saying to Kitt, I have to pace myself in terms of how quickly I reveal the info - now I know where I'm going (and it's not where I thought I was going originally, but then again it never is) I can't wait to share it with the readers. Glad you enjoyed the dialogue, too; I enjoyed writing it. Thank you for reading and reviewing, as ever!
Date: Jun 29 2009
Title: Chapter 11: A Visitor Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
I went through and read other reviews of this chapter and the last chapter, and I'm so relieved to see that I'm not the only one wondering about Aiken. I'm not sure it's intended on your part, but I'm feeling kind of sympathetic toward him...wondering how he feels about Beomia, if he loves her or is attracted to her at all. His taciturn manner intrigues me, making me wonder what's going on in his head. Of course, this likely has more to do with me than with anything else; I'm intrigued by quiet men, and I'm old enough to find the right kind of fortyish balding man sexy. ;-)

Author's Response: Haha!! Actually, it wasn't my intention to have readers feeling sympathy for Aiken - yet. He comes more into his own further in, and it is made clear how he feels about Beomia. I'm glad I've got you wondering, though! Thank you so much for keeping with the story and leaving feedback :-)
Date: Sep 07 2009
Title: Chapter 14: Isabel Jane Murphy Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
This is a lovely chapter, full of nuanced character dynamics and thoughtful pacing.

You've wandered far and wide from the original premise, but you've done it in a way that brings unique depth and resonance to the original premise. This story is about so much more than reincarnation in Middle-earth as an animal; it's about grief, families, love, and the negotiation of human life from one moment to the next. I look forward to you conclusion because I know that it will be handled with grace and skill.

You just keep getting better and better! Brava, darling. :-)

Author's Response: Thank you so much! *Grins* yes, I have somewhat strayed from my original intentions...this was supposed to be two or three chapters long, a quick distraction while I was blocked on other stuff!! Ah well, nothing ever turns out as you mean it to, and I like it better this way. There's still more twisting and turning to be done yet; even though I wrote out a complete draft over summer, I keep on thinking of things that need to be added in. As for handling the conclusion, I only hope that it meets your expectations - you've given me a lot to live up to! Thanks for reading and reviewing, as always. It's much appreciated.

Date: Oct 20 2009
Title: Chapter 15: A Voice Quiet And Brief Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
Oooh, change of perspective. I'm intrigued.

Author's Response: Good to hear! :D I've been messing with the perspective a lot in these last few chapters (Derry, Annis), simply because I felt those POVs were right for the action...ah well. As usual, story's in charge, not me. Thanks for R&Ring!
Date: Oct 22 2009
Summary: The long-lost daughter of Elrond was transported to modern-day Earth when she was an infant. Now that she is almost an adult, she finds herself in Rivendell once again. She falls for Glorfindel, the captain of her father's soldiers. The only problem? Glorfindel's wife isn't too happy.
Categories: Book-verse Characters: Elladan, Elrohir, Elrond, Glorfindel, Original Character, Other Canon Character
Genres: Action/Adventure, Angst, Parody, Romance
Warnings: AU (alternate universe), Character Death
Series: None
Chapters: 2 Table of Contents
Completed: No Word count: 1118 Read Count: 2420
Published: Apr 11 2009 Updated: Apr 12 2009 [Report This]
Title: Chapter 1: Prologue, or, In Which We Are Introduced To The Herione Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
"Ahhhh! My eyeballs have melted. And are bleeding. Do not ask me why I endeavored to write this." Ummmm...because it's funny? ;-)

Author's Response: Thank you for the review! But no, I wrote this to show how well-written Sues screw with character, though sometimes we as readers don't notice it because of the correct punctuation and flowery language. SiM
Date: Apr 12 2009

Moriah is your standard college girl. Nothing out of the ordinary. So why are there nine confused travellers at her dorm? I promise this is not a Sue-fic.

Categories: Crossovers, Off Topic Characters: Original Character, The Fellowship
Genres: Fantasy, General, Humor
Warnings: None
Series: None
Chapters: 7 Table of Contents
Completed: No Word count: 3948 Read Count: 7938
Published: May 04 2009 Updated: Aug 02 2009 [Report This]
Title: Chapter 4: Pippin's in my Parking Lot, Doo-dah, Doo-dah. Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
You're quite good with the humor. You should write it more often. :)

Author's Response: Thank you so much!
Date: May 12 2009
Title: Chapter 1: I swear to God, I'm not tripping. Reviewer: Pink Siamese Signed
"Except for the fifteen bajillion tons of snow that we get all the time." Bwahahahahah it's so true. I'm laughing like this because the snow is finally all gone. And we have leaves and flowers and things. This is always a really exciting development for a Mainer. Love the humor. :)

Author's Response:

Whenever I would talk to my older sister about how college was in Maine, she would always talk about the "fifteen bajillion tons of snow" and how cold it was. We are Connecticut girls ourselves, so Maine is akin to the North Pole to us. Gotta love the warm winter wear of L.L. Bean, which we oh so wisely heaped up on my sister before she went to college there.

I'm sure Maine is absolutely beautiful in the spring. I've been there in the summer maybe once, and from what I saw it was absolutely gorgeous; I loved it.

Thanks for the compliment on the humor, though the real kudos should go to my older sister...I'm only writing from what I feel would be her point of view, so she's really the funny one here.

Date: May 04 2009