:D

Fantastic story! I love it.

Elf lords need to have fun too!

HAHAHA!

Boys and their toys...

I love it!

Cirdan is a favorite character of mine and this makes him even more so.

Thank you for this! :D

Ahhh...these are the stories that stay with me because it shows, beyond a shadow of a doubt, that elves like more than just beauty and...er...well beauty. ;)

Well done!

This makes me happier than you can know. :D Really. We hates standardized testing, we does. Great job!

:D What a delightful story! Elrond's reactions were absolutely perfect, and I love how Erestor went about drawing his own conclusions as logically and diplomatically as possible. Not to mention the memory of attempting to burp in appreciation while drinking with Dwarves. heehee. Great job!

Author's Response: Thank you so much! Your review is like an unexpected Christmas present. :-) Trying to figure out how a person raised according to the norms of 'The Laws and Customs of the Eldar' would view - and react to - 'normal' human behaviour was quite challenging, but also great fun. It's wonderful to hear that you enjoyed what I came up with!

I really like this, and am tending to agree with your second reviewer-don't worry about writing a tenth walker fic. It's not worth it. In fact, I think this is a delightful twist on the usual Mary-Sue/tenth walker story and will be looking for more.

Also, I love the fact that your protagonist is not the most wonderful, skillful person you would ever want to meet. It is quite refreshing to have a 'real' protagonist.

Keep it up!

Author's Response: Thank you! It’s absolutely wonderful to wake up and find that someone has left such a kind review. I’ll definitely write on and I’ll post more. Thanks!

I have to agree with everyone else, it is quite nice to see a story that at least tries to create what it would actually be like to be transported to another world. :) Certainly...all my girl-falls in to ME stories I would not actually write and publish because they're too Mary Sue like. :P lol. Purely for my own -ahem- enjoyment.

And the "fantasy" line was indeed spot on. :D

Keep it up!

~bp~

Author's Response: Thank you so much! This started off as a plot bunny that would just not go away until I started working on it and it was just a fun side project, a little crack!fic where I was determined not to get too carried away with the why and just let it carry me wherever I would though on that same note I did try to handle it with some realism instead of the usual "Woah, so cool! Where do I meet the guys?" This is for my enjoyment as well, It is meant as some fun and so I am doing my best to keep it that way and just letting the story go wherever it wants. Thanks again for your kind words, such reviews are definitely encouraging.