Reviews For Elven Homecomings
You must login (register) to review.
Title: Off to Rivendell Reviewer: iggybaby Signed
very good chapter. "Woodpecker" hee hee hee. funny. about your question, I think you could have romance as long as you don't make aniel perfect. The thing with mary-sues, they're perfect and they usually fall in love, ending being happily married, ect. Now, let's say if they got attacked going to rivendell, aniel shouldn't just pick up a sword and start killing. i don't think she knows how to wield a weapon. if you want her to fight, then have a few chapters where legolas and/or aragorn teach her the ways of war. if you have anymore questions, because i have an idea but not the whole picture, i suggest you post a question or e-mail the web-master. i did that and got a better view of this site.
iggybaby

Author's Response: I'm glad you liked :D Yep, Aniel def isn't perfect and you are right she can't fight to save her life. Okay, since the romance bits are already written I'll keep them in there. If its too nausiating for people I guess they'll have to stop reading (if anyone else is still reading). Thx for your review :)
Date: Feb 03 2007 06:59 pm [Report This]
Title: Chapter 4 Reviewer: iggybaby Signed
*waves hands in front of face as if to cool down* That was so... uncalled for! That... that elf should know better! he's disgusted me!
iggybaby

Author's Response: That elf is going to get worse. These elves are not quite like their kindred we are used to. Thanks so much for reading. By the way, I'm new to LOTR fanfics so.... should I avoid romance in this story? I'm confused about the Sue thing, now I'm thinking romance is a bad idea?
Date: Jan 29 2007 04:57 pm [Report This]
Title: A New Threat Reviewer: iggybaby Signed
eee. The Exiles! I wonder where they were exiled to? It must a long ways away fro gondor and harad, right?
iggybaby

Author's Response: Weird thing is, Tolkien did have a group of elves he called "The Exiles" which I didn't know about when I started this. Except that they were Noldor and mine are Avari, a different race. The last time I read the Silmarilion (think it's covered there?) was in 1987 or something...Anyways....I've placed the Avari floating around south of Harad...since they never went to Valinor like the other races. I don't think it's specified where they are meant to be, so I put them there. They were too cowardly to help out in the War of the Ring, (which they must have known about?) But now that Sauron is defeated, they've decided to come North. And claim it, who knows lol. Have to wait and see! Sorry about rambling! I might change the name of this to Elven Exiles....hmm.
Date: Jan 18 2007 05:12 pm [Report This]
Title: Chapter 2 Reviewer: iggybaby Signed
I wonder if legolas will have some more part if this story.
iggybaby

Author's Response: You will find out in the very next chapter....which will be going up very soon.
Date: Jan 15 2007 06:04 pm [Report This]
Title: First Meetings Reviewer: iggybaby Signed
This is awesome!
iggybaby

Author's Response: Thanks!
Date: Jan 15 2007 05:34 pm [Report This]
Title: First Meetings Reviewer: elfenears Signed
really good start keep it up

Author's Response: Thank you! More will be coming soon.
Date: Jan 13 2007 05:37 am [Report This]
You must login (register) to review.